SATURDAY | MIKE’S DESK

 

❝

TL;DR: The businesses buyers fall in love with, coffee shops, breweries, gyms, bookstores, tend to come with emotional prices, thin earnings and owners who want to change everything on day one. Love makes you skip the math. The rule for first-time buyers is simple: love the business model, not the product.

The most expensive advisor in any deal is your own heart.

I've watched it happen dozens of times. A buyer spends months looking at HVAC companies and distribution businesses with clean numbers. Then a coffee shop comes on the market in the neighborhood where he used to live. Or a brewery. Or a bookstore, a boutique gym, a vineyard tasting room. And suddenly the spreadsheet doesn't matter anymore.

He's not buying a business. He's buying a feeling. And that feeling has a price.

Why Love Is So Expensive

Here's what happens when you fall in love with a business. First, you stop running the numbers the same way. A deal you'd pass on in ten minutes gets a second look, then a third, then a story about why this one is different.

Second, you're not the only one in love. The businesses people dream about owning attract a lot of dreamers. More buyers with the same feeling means higher asking prices, and sellers know it. You end up paying an emotional premium on top of an already thin business.

Third, you want to change it. People who love a product have opinions about it. The menu, the decor, the brand. The thing the business does that customers actually pay for gets rearranged to match what the new owner imagines it should be. Sometimes that works. Often it breaks the very thing that made the business earn money.

Watch What the Numbers Say

Let me show you on a composite deal. A well-loved coffee shop earning $180,000 in SDE. The seller wants $650,000, about 3.6x. The buyer, a marketing executive who's dreamed of owning a café for ten years, is ready to pay it.

With a clean 80/10/10 at 10.5%, his SBA payment is $7,017 a month and his total debt service is $87,449 a year. Coverage is 2.06x. Stressed coverage after a 20% drop is 1.65x. After paying a $75,000 general manager, owner cash flow is $17,551 a year. That's not a business. That's a very expensive job you'd have to show up to every morning.

Even at a disciplined 2.75x, $495,000, owner cash flow after a manager is only about $38,400. Stressed coverage clears at 2.16x, but the business is simply too small to pay a manager and still pay the owner what I want on any deal, $100,000 a year.

Now take the same $650,000 to a business nobody dreams about. A commercial cleaning company earning $270,000. Same price, same loan, same payment. Stressed coverage is 2.47x. Owner cash flow after a manager is about $107,500. Nobody puts a picture of it on Instagram. It just pays.

A business you love will ask you to pay for the feeling. A business you don't love will just pay you.

There's a fourth cost, and it's the one that hurts most. Passion businesses tend to need the owner. The barista who knows every regular's order, the brewer whose recipes are the product, the trainer whose clients follow her, not the gym. When the thing customers love is a person, the business gets harder to step back from, harder to hand to a manager and much harder to sell later. You end up working for a business that was supposed to work for you. Most buyers I talk to left corporate jobs to get their time back. A business you love that also owns your evenings and weekends isn't freedom. It's a different boss.

The Exception, and How to Use It

I want to be careful here, because I'm not telling you to buy something you hate. You'll be living with this business for years. You should like it.

The difference is what you love. Love the business model, not the product. Love recurring revenue. Love customers who need what you sell every month whether the economy is good or bad. Love a team that runs the place without you standing behind the counter. Love the boring, predictable parts, because those are the parts that pay down your loan.

I sat with a buyer last year who was set on a craft brewery. Great beer. Great taproom. Earnings that only worked if he worked the bar himself six nights a week. We ran the numbers together and he went quiet. Three months later he bought a beverage distribution business that delivers to bars and restaurants, including that brewery. He still gets to be in the business he loves. He just owns the part of it that makes money.

After 35 years in private equity, that's the move I'd suggest to anyone with a passion they can't shake. Find the business that serves the thing you love. The supplier, the distributor, the repair company, the service provider behind the scenes. You stay close to what you care about, and you own the part with better economics.

Here's the thing nobody mentions. Sellers of passion businesses are often in love too, and their asking price is partly the value of their own dream. That doesn't make it your price.

Run the numbers before you let yourself care. Score every deal the same way, especially the ones you want. I run every listing through DealScore Pro before I let myself picture owning it. If it doesn't clear, the feeling doesn't get a vote.

Write down what you'd change. If your list is long, you're not buying the business. You're buying a project, and you should price it like one.

Ask who it works for without you. If the business only earns money when the owner is behind the counter, you're buying a job, not an asset.

Buy with your head. Then you can enjoy it with your heart.

What This Means For You

If you catch yourself falling for a business, run it through the same five criteria you use on everything else before you make an offer. If the numbers don't work, look for the business that serves what you love instead of the business you love.

— Mike

Want to see how I stress-test every deal against cost shocks, revenue dips, and hidden liabilities before I'd put a dollar at risk? I walk through the entire Bulletproof method in a free 28-minute masterclass.

DealScore Pro - Free Deal Calculator

Score any deal in 60 seconds

Plug in any listing and see the Bulletproof Score instantly. Free, no signup required.
Free 28-Minute Bulletproof Masterclass with Mike Warren

Watch the Free 28-Minute Masterclass

See exactly how I stress-test every deal before I'd put a dollar at risk.

Real Estate Is for Suckers - Free Book by Mike Warren

Know someone thinking about buying a business?

Forward this email. Tell them to grab Mike's free book - Real Estate Is for Suckers: Buy a Business Instead. Same framework Mike uses to stress-test every deal.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate