THURSDAY | MARKET PULSE

TL;DR: When the seller owns the building, the rent in the P&L is whatever he decided to charge himself. If it's below market, earnings drop the day you sign a real lease. On a composite $1.1M deal, a $5,000-a-month rent gap pushes stressed coverage from 2.16x to 1.84x. And buying the building got pricier: SBA 504 debentures priced at 6.97% in October, up from about 6.54% a month earlier.
When the seller is also the landlord, the rent on the P&L is whatever he decided to charge himself.
This is one of the most common setups on Main Street. The owner buys the building through a separate LLC years ago and leases it to the business. It's a smart move for him. It builds equity, and it gives him control over his biggest fixed cost.
For you, it creates a problem most buyers never catch. That rent was never negotiated by two strangers. It was set by one person sitting on both sides of the table, and it can be almost anything.
The Rent Nobody Negotiated
Owners who are their own landlords set rent for their own reasons. Some charge themselves very little because the mortgage is paid off and they never thought about it. Some keep it low because it makes the business look more profitable. A few charge more than market for tax or cash reasons. Either way, the number on the P&L is not the number you'll pay.
And here's what happens at closing. Most sellers who own the building want to keep it and lease it to you. The new lease gets written at something close to market rent, because that's what the seller wants and usually what the lender and appraiser expect. The day that lease starts, the earnings you paid for change.
Let me show you on a composite deal. A commercial services business earning $400,000 in SDE. The seller's LLC owns the 5,000-square-foot building and charges the business $3,000 a month. Comparable space nearby leases for about $8,000 a month.
Price it at 2.75x and you're paying $1.1M. With a clean 80/10/10 at 10.5%, your SBA payment is $11,874 a month, your total debt service is $147,991 a year, and stressed coverage after a 20% drop is 2.16x. It passes.
Now sign a market-rate lease. That's $5,000 more a month, $60,000 a year. Your SDE drops to $340,000. Stressed coverage falls to 1.84x. It fails. Priced at 2.75x the earnings you'll actually have, the business is worth $935,000. You'd be overpaying by $165,000.
Below-market rent isn't a gift from the seller. It's earnings that disappear the day you sign the lease.
It can cut the other way, too. If the seller charges himself more than market, the business earns more than the P&L shows. That's real upside, but verify it with comparables before you count on it.
Should You Buy the Building Too?
Sometimes the seller wants to sell the real estate with the business. That can be a great move. You lock in your occupancy cost, you stop worrying about a landlord, and you build equity. But it costs more cash at closing, and the financing just got more expensive.
Most buyers use the SBA 504 program for owner-occupied real estate. A typical 504 deal is 50% from a bank, 40% from an SBA-backed debenture through a local CDC, and 10% from you. The debenture rate is set at a monthly sale and pegged to the 10-year Treasury, which stood at 5.27% on October 6. At the October 8 sale, standard 20- and 25-year debentures priced at 6.97% including fees, according to rate tables published by CDCs, up from about 6.54% in September. You can see how the program works on SBA.gov.
On a $1.2M building, the 40% debenture is $480,000. Over 25 years at 6.97%, that piece runs about $3,383 a month, roughly $1,564 a year more than at September's rate. That's one month of rate movement on one piece of the financing. The bank's 50% first mortgage is priced separately and moves with the market too.
And don't forget your 10%. On that same building, it's $120,000 of cash on top of the down payment and working capital for the business itself.
I worked with a buyer a few years ago who chose to lease instead of buy. Smart call at the time. But his lease was five years with no renewal option, and the seller still owned the building. At year five, the seller's kids had taken over the LLC, and the new rent came in 40% higher. He had nowhere to go. A business that depends on its location is only as safe as its lease.
The Move When the Seller Owns the Real Estate
After 35 years of looking at these, I can tell you the real estate is where good businesses quietly become bad deals. Here's how I handle it.
Get market rent from someone who isn't the seller. Call a commercial real estate broker in the area and ask for three comparable leases per square foot. It takes one phone call and it's the most important number in the deal.
Rerun the deal at market rent. Swap the seller's rent for the market number and run it again. That's how I set price in DealScore Pro, on the rent you'll actually pay, not the rent the seller charged himself.
Negotiate the lease at the same time as the purchase. The lease should be signed before you close, not handed to you afterward. Ask for a term with renewal options that covers at least the life of your SBA loan, fixed annual increases, and a right of first refusal if the seller ever sells the building.
Run the buy decision separately. Ask what the building would cost, what the 504 financing looks like today, and how much extra cash it takes. Then decide whether you're buying a business, a building, or both. Don't let one quietly pay for the other.
Banks won't push on this. The appraiser may assume market rent, but nobody will walk you through what it does to your price. Neither will the broker. The seller is his client, and the seller wears two hats.
Here's the good news. Once you know the real rent, the conversation with the seller gets simple. Either the price reflects market rent, or the lease does. Most reasonable sellers understand that once you show them the math.
What This Means For You
If you're looking at a business where the owner also owns the building, get three market rent comparables before you make an offer and rerun the deal at that rent. Then negotiate the lease terms and the purchase price together, and decide separately whether buying the building makes sense for your cash.
— Mike
Want to see how I stress-test every deal against cost shocks, revenue dips, and hidden liabilities before I'd put a dollar at risk? I walk through the entire Bulletproof method in a free 28-minute masterclass.

Score any deal in 60 seconds
Plug in any listing and see the Bulletproof Score instantly. Free, no signup required.

Watch the Free 28-Minute Masterclass
See exactly how I stress-test every deal before I'd put a dollar at risk.

Know someone thinking about buying a business?
Forward this email. Tell them to grab Mike's free book - Real Estate Is for Suckers: Buy a Business Instead. Same framework Mike uses to stress-test every deal.


