THURSDAY | MARKET PULSE

 

❝

TL;DR: Nearly 300 insurers offering small group health coverage proposed a median 14% premium increase for 2027, according to KFF. That renewal hits most target businesses on January 1 and shows up nowhere in the trailing numbers. If you're leaving a corporate job, your own family's coverage becomes your bill too. Both are knowable before you sign, so price them in.

There's a letter sitting in your seller's inbox right now that changes the deal. Nobody on your side has read it.

It's the health insurance renewal. For businesses with a January 1 plan year, the renewal usually lands in the fall. This year it's going to sting. In August, KFF looked at preliminary rate filings from all 50 states and DC. Nearly 300 insurers that sell small group coverage proposed a median increase of 14% for 2027. You can read the analysis on KFF.

The insurers point to the usual suspects: higher prices for hospital stays, doctors and prescription drugs, more people using care, and a shrinking pool of small businesses still buying group plans. That last one matters. As healthier groups leave, the ones still in the pool pay more.

Put that on top of where costs already were. In KFF's 2025 Employer Health Benefits Survey, the average family premium hit $26,993. At firms with 10 to 199 workers, the average family plan cost $26,054, and workers paid $8,889 of it themselves. Only 59% of firms that size offered health coverage at all.

Why This Line Gets Missed

Here's the problem. The P&L in your data room shows last year's premium. The renewal is a forward-looking number, and it takes effect on January 1, often weeks after you close or right in the middle of your first quarter as the owner.

Unlike fuel prices or a slow season, this isn't a guess. It's a contract price. The insurer has already quoted it, or will shortly. That makes it one of the few cost increases in a deal you can know before you sign. Most buyers never ask.

Part of the reason is where it hides. Benefits usually get lumped into a line like "payroll taxes and benefits," and brokers rarely break it out. You see one big number that looks like it went up a little last year, and you move on.

There's a second risk most people miss. When a renewal comes in hot, owners have two choices: eat it, or push more of the cost onto employees. A seller trying to protect his sale price might do the second one quietly before closing. That saves him money on paper. It costs you the techs with families who just watched their paycheck shrink.

Watch What 14% Does to a Real Deal

Let me show you on a composite deal. A home services business earning $320,000 in SDE. Fourteen employees on the group plan, and the business pays about $11,000 a year for each one. That's $154,000 a year in health premiums.

Price it at 2.75x and you're paying $880,000. With a clean 80/10/10 at 10.5%, your SBA payment is $9,499 a month and your total debt service is $118,393 a year. Stressed coverage after a 20% earnings drop is 2.16x. After paying a $75,000 general manager, your owner cash flow is $126,607.

Now apply the renewal. Fourteen percent on $154,000 is $21,560 a year. Your SDE drops to $298,440. Stressed coverage falls to 2.02x. It still clears, barely. But priced at 2.75x the earnings you'll actually have, the business is worth about $820,700. That's roughly $59,000 less than the price built on last year's premium.

The renewal letter is the one cost increase in the deal you can know before you sign.

Then there's the second hit, and this one lands on your kitchen table. Most buyers leaving a corporate job have family coverage through their employer. The day you leave, that becomes your bill. A family plan that averaged about $27,000 last year runs closer to $30,800 after a 14% increase.

In most SDE calculations, the owner's own health insurance is already added back, so the number counts it as your money. That's correct. It just means about $30,800 of your owner cash flow is spoken for before you buy a single bag of groceries. In this deal, the $105,047 left after the renewal is closer to $74,000 of money you can actually spend. That isn't a reason the deal fails my test. It's a line in your family budget your employer used to pay, and you need to plan for it.

I watched this catch a buyer last year. His renewal showed up three weeks after closing, up 19%. He hadn't asked for it. He chose to push more of the cost to his team, and two of his best technicians were gone within 60 days. The premium increase was about $18,000. Replacing those two techs cost him far more.

The Move Before You Sign

After 35 years of reading P&Ls, I can tell you the costs that hurt new owners most are rarely the ones that are hard to find. They're the ones nobody thought to ask about.

Ask for the renewal in writing before your LOI is final. If it hasn't arrived, ask for the insurance broker's estimate and the last three years of renewal history. A business whose premiums jumped 12%, 15% and 18% is telling you where next year is headed.

Break benefits out of the payroll line. How many employees are enrolled? What does the business pay per person? What do employees contribute? Who's on family coverage? Those four answers tell you how exposed the business is.

Rerun the deal at the renewal number. Take the increase off SDE and run it again. That's exactly what I do in DealScore Pro before I talk price.

Price your own family's coverage now. Get a real quote before you resign from anything. Find out whether you can join the business's group plan as the owner and what it costs. Then put that number in your personal budget, not just the deal model.

Lock benefit levels in the LOI. Ask the seller to keep plan design and employee contributions unchanged through closing. If anything changes, it should be your decision as the new owner, not his on the way out.

Banks won't catch this one. The lender underwrites trailing earnings, and the renewal isn't in them. Neither will the broker. His job is the sale price, and this number only makes it go down.

Now, some perspective. Premiums go up almost every year, and a 14% increase on a healthy business is manageable. This isn't a reason to stop buying. It's a reason to know the number before the seller does the math for you.

Price the business on next year's bills, not last year's.

What This Means For You

If you're planning to acquire in the next six months, ask every seller for the 2027 health insurance renewal and three years of renewal history before you finalize price. Then get your own family's coverage quoted and add it to your personal budget before you give notice anywhere.

— Mike

Want to see how I stress-test every deal against cost shocks, revenue dips, and hidden liabilities before I'd put a dollar at risk? I walk through the entire Bulletproof method in a free 28-minute masterclass.

DealScore Pro - Free Deal Calculator

Score any deal in 60 seconds

Plug in any listing and see the Bulletproof Score instantly. Free, no signup required.
Free 28-Minute Bulletproof Masterclass with Mike Warren

Watch the Free 28-Minute Masterclass

See exactly how I stress-test every deal before I'd put a dollar at risk.

Real Estate Is for Suckers - Free Book by Mike Warren

Know someone thinking about buying a business?

Forward this email. Tell them to grab Mike's free book - Real Estate Is for Suckers: Buy a Business Instead. Same framework Mike uses to stress-test every deal.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate